Know your cattle, grid conditions
by Steve Suther
Commodity cattle are priced by weight class, sex or average carcass grade, but some are worth a lot more or less. Indeed, some producers carve out a reputation, a kind of brand for their consistently high-quality cattle akin to that of Mercedes-Benz®, Apple® or Rolex®.
Pete Anderson, Ag Knowledge Services, says owners of those better cattle should earn premiums, but producing them is just the first step on the way to capturing value. “Grid marketing of fed cattle is one way to get paid a premium for producing something that is superior to the average,” he notes in a new white paper.
“Understanding grid marketing: How quality grades and grid conditions affect carcass value” is available with its several tables at https://cabcattle.com/research .
The subject may seem “a little mysterious and risky to some, especially feeder cattle producers who are new to retained ownership or only market cattle once or twice a year,” Anderson says. It helps to know how grids work and how your finished cattle will perform.
The Choice-Select spread is a key to many premiums and discounts, published daily by USDA and based on sales of primal cuts. On February 15, 2012, for example, the $5.11 per hundredweight (/cwt.) spread came from the range of a $19.95/cwt. Choice premium on loins to a Choice discount (-$3.40/cwt.) for the short plate.
In 2011, a particularly volatile year, the spread ranged from near $0 to more than $18/cwt., with exaggerated seasonality. Typical seasonal supply factors are higher grades in the winter, lighter carcasses in spring and fewer finished cattle in summer. On the demand side, the grilling season supports steaks and burgers while the fall and winter holidays focus on roasts from the chuck and round. The economy, exports and decisions of large companies are nonseasonal influences, Anderson adds.
The higher the Choice-Select spread, the more premium for quality cattle. “But with grid pricing, what looks like simple math is often not so simple,” he says. Mastering the math means figuring in a few more factors.
“The first of these is the percentage Choice requirement (Choice base) required to get par value,” Anderson explains. Each grid publishes its Choice base under terms and conditions; sometimes it’s a fixed number but more often it is a moving target like a plant average. Either way, as the hurdle required for par moves higher, all cattle are worth less money above average. “That’s because premiums are generated not by the absolute number of Choice cattle, but by the amount by which your cattle clear the hurdle set by the grid,” he says (See Box).
Beyond Choice and Select, cattle that grade USDA Prime or qualify for Certified Angus Beef ® (CAB®) or other branded programs receive premium prices, and those can be substantial, Anderson says. For example, if 40% of your cattle make CAB at $4/cwt. more, it amounts to another $12.80 on the pen average, figuring 800-pound carcass weights. Prime premiums can run much higher, but even at $15/cwt., your 800-lb. carcasses grading 20% Prime add $24 to the per-head pen average.
Heavily discounted quality grades can be a problem in some sets cattle. USDA Standard grade beef has almost no marbling, and its likely unsatisfactory eating experience brings the discount. The table (below) shows an example of how low- or high-grading cattle could compare in premiums and discounts, and the impact on cattle value. In this case, cattle grading 50% Choice would bring the average market price, Anderson notes.
“Remember, it is not enough to create cattle with high value,” he says. “You need to find a way to capture that value and put it in your pocket.”
You may also like
Producers can target cow herd genetics toward the factors driving value in the supply chain. Backfat and marbling have differing value implications at the packing plant and can be selected in different directions in the herd. Understanding grid marketing opens more opportunity for big wins.
“No man’s land.” Select seems to find itself there more these days. This article shares some examples of declining demand for the lower quality grade, and what that communicates to cattlemen.
Many cattlemen have an idea of how grid marketing works, but might still have some questions as they’re digging through carcass data. Paul Dykstra will present a free webinar, “Understanding grid marketing and carcass data,” on January 21, 2021 at 1:30 p.m. CST.